Rated & Reviewed is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Learn more.
If you’re a quesadilla lover, you know that the perfect quesadilla can turn any meal into a fiesta. Whether you prefer traditional Mexican-style quesadillas or get creative with your fillings, having the right quesadilla maker can make all the difference. In this comprehensive guide, we reviewed several highly rated options and then crowned our pick for the best quesadilla maker of 2023, and help you find the one that suits your needs perfectly. From budget-friendly options to high-end multipurpose grills, we’ve got you covered.
Which is the best quesadilla maker? We rated the George Foreman Electric Quesadilla Maker as best overall. It has the best combination of affordability, function and a form factor we liked.
Here’s the how all the quesadilla makers we rated. Keep reading to see more.
| Rating | Product Name | Full Review |
|---|---|---|
| Best Overall | George Foreman Electric Quesadilla Maker | Jump to Review |
| Best Budget | Hamilton Beach Quesadilla Maker | Jump to Review |
| Runner-Up, Best Budget | Elite Gourmet Mexican Taco Tuesday Quesadilla Maker | Jump to Review |
| Best Multipurpose | George Foreman 2-Serving Classic Plate Electric Indoor Grill | Jump to Review |
| Best High-End | Breville BGR700BSS The Sear and Press Countertop Electric Grill | Jump to Review |
| Best for the Grill | Outset Quesadilla Basket | Jump to Review |
| Best Comal | Victoria Cast Iron Round Pan Comal Griddle | Jump to Review |
| Best Mini | Nostalgia MyMini Personal Sandwich Maker | Jump to Review |
Why You Need a Quesadilla Maker
Quesadilla makers are more than just a kitchen gadget; they are a must-have for quesadilla enthusiasts. These dedicated appliances are designed to create perfectly toasted quesadillas with even heating and easy cleanup. No more flipping quesadillas on a stovetop pan and worrying about cheese spilling out – a quesadilla maker takes care of it all.
Our Top Picks
1. George Foreman Electric Quesadilla Maker – Best Overall
The George Foreman Electric Quesadilla Maker takes the top spot on our list for its ease of use and reliability. With a 10-inch cooking diameter and six deep pockets, this machine allows you to stuff your quesadillas generously. The stacked tortilla cooking method ensures a larger surface area of cheese and tortilla, resulting in a mouthwatering quesadilla in under five minutes. Cleanup is a breeze with the nonstick George Tough coating, and its vertical storage design saves counter space.
2. Hamilton Beach Quesadilla Maker – Best Budget
For those looking for a budget-friendly option, the Hamilton Beach Quesadilla Maker is a solid pick. It accommodates 6- or 8-inch tortillas and features an easy-to-clean nonstick surface that delivers perfectly crisp exteriors. The preheat light ensures you know when the machine is ready to use, and its upright storage design saves space in your kitchen.
- Hot & ready to eat in about 5 minutes; makes 6 wedges
- Nonstick surface wipes clean
- Satisfy your appetite for restaurant quality right at home
- Locking lid for less mess & upright storage
- Power & preheat lights
3. Elite Gourmet Mexican Taco Tuesday Quesadilla Maker – Runner-Up, Best Budget
The Elite Gourmet Mexican Taco Tuesday Quesadilla Maker combines function with fashion, with a fun pepper design and an 8-inch cooking surface. The plates are divided into triangles, making it easy to cut your quesadilla. The removable drip tray and nonstick plates make cleanup a breeze, and its upright storage design ensures it won’t take up much space.
- 8-Inch Cooking Surface: Cook 6 Quesadilla Wedges On The Large 8-Inch Nonstick Cooking Surface In Just Under 5-Minutes. Cheesy, Melty And Delicious Snacks
- Easy Cleanup: When You’Re Done Making The Quesadillas On The Nonstick Hot Plate, Simply Wipe Clean The Cooking Surface, Do Not Use Abrasive Cleansers
- Compact Storage: The Unit Stands Vertical For A Convenient And Tidy Upright Storage After You’Re Done Cooking. Drainage Rim & Drip Tray: Catch Any Drippings In The Drip Tray Located Underneath The Unit. Reduce Grease For A Healthy Snack
- Indicator Lights: Two Indicator Lights Let You Know When The Unit Has Power And When The Unit Is Preheated And Ready For Cooking
4. George Foreman 2-Serving Classic Plate Electric Indoor Grill – Best Multipurpose
If you prefer a multitasking machine, the George Foreman 2-Serving Classic Plate Electric Indoor Grill is the way to go. This versatile appliance can sear steaks, grill chicken, press paninis, and make delicious quesadillas. The floating hinge accommodates thicker quesadillas, and the nonstick coating ensures easy cleaning. Its compact size is perfect for cooking for two, and it stores effortlessly on its side.
- 2 Servings – Tight on countertop space? This grill is your answer. It fits two servings of your grilled favorites, and it’s perfect for small apartments and couples.
- New Space-Saving Design* – With a low profile and vertical storage capabilities, it’s simple to fit the grill in small spaces on your countertop or in the cupboard.
- Advanced George Tough Nonstick Coating – There’s a lot to love about this nonstick coating. It’s 3x more durable**, easy to clean, and removes the need for butter and oil.
- Adjustable Grilling Angle – Set the grill at an angle to remove excess fat during grilling, or put it flat for panini and other toasting tasks. The hinged grill legs are simple to adjust.
- Exclusive Fat-Removing Slope – It’s the sure sign of a George Foreman Grill. The sloped grilling surface helps remove excess fat for tasty meals and healthy grilling. Perfect for individuals or couples
5. Breville Sear and Press Countertop Electric Grill – Best High-End
For those seeking a high-end option, the Breville Sear and Press Countertop Electric Grill is a top-notch choice. This grill features reversible ceramic grill and griddle plates, offering versatility for all your cooking needs. It can accommodate up to 12-inch tortillas, making it perfect for larger quesadillas. With independent temperature controls and a max temperature of 450 degrees, you can achieve that perfect crisp exterior and mouthwatering taste. Cleanup is a breeze with the removable/reversible plates.
- ONE-TOUCH PRESETS: Shortcuts increase convenience: pre-programmed one-touch Panini, Burger and Sear functionalities create ideal cooking environment and perfect results for your favorite foods.
- OPEN FLAT BBQ MODE: Open the grill flat for a 240 square inch grilling and griddle surface. Makes grilling steaks, burgers or seafood a cinch and cooks eggs and pancakes to perfection. Removable drip tray works in BBQ or contact mode and catches the fat whilst cooking. Outdoor grilling has now found a new home on your countertop.
- INDEPENDENT PLATE TEMPERATURE CONTROL: The electronic temperature control on each plate puts you in command. When opened on the BBQ mode, you now have the ability to cook a great variety of food that require different temperatures independently. Endless food combinations to keep you cooking morning, noon and night.
- REVERSIBLE CERAMIC GRILL AND GRIDDLE PLATES: Sizzle bacon and eggs for breakfast, toast panini sandwiches for lunch, cook steaks for dinner, make waffles for dessert. Non-stick and natural coating enables the dual sided convenience. With hotter temperatures, ceramic plates allow more browning, better crust and are completely PFOA and PTFE free.
- WAFFLE PLATES COMPATIBLE: Add versatility to your grill with premium quick release non-stick coating ceramic waffle plates (sold separately). The No-mess Moat design feature prevents waffle batter to spill out and onto your countertop. Dishwasher safe.
6. Outset Quesadilla Basket – Best for the Grill
For the outdoor cooking enthusiasts, the Outset Quesadilla Basket is a perfect choice. Made of heavy-gauged chrome steel with a rosewood handle, this basket locks your quesadilla in place to heat over a grill or campfire. Its 12-inch size can hold a large tortilla stuffed with cheese and other fillings, and it gives your quesadilla that smoky, flame-broiled flavor. Perfect for camping, barbecues, and outdoor parties.
- 12″ x 16″
- Heavy-gauge chromed steel with a fine rosewood handle, which conducts heat slowly to minimize burns
- Convenient locking mechanism fastens closed for easy storage
- Basket and easy-slide lock molds and holds food securely in place
- Great tool to bring camping
7. Victoria Cast Iron Round Pan Comal Griddle – Best Comal
If you love the authentic flavor of comal-cooked quesadillas, the Victoria Cast Iron Round Pan Comal Griddle is the ideal choice. Made from recycled cast iron and pre-seasoned with flaxseed oil, this 10.5-inch flat surface is perfect for large quesadillas. It also works well for other dishes like crepes, pizza, and pancakes.
- CAST IRON COOKING: Our cast iron round pan features a perfectly textured preseasoned skin that helps build seasoning with each use and offers an easier release. We use only non-GMO, kosher-certified flaxseed oil to season it, and it’s free of PTFE and PFOA for healthier cooking.
- MADE FOR GREAT MEALS: This cast iron pan has excellent heat retention and distribution that keeps your food hot and ready to serve. The long handle stays cool as you cook on the stove top, and it’s easy to grip to move this cookware from the BBQ, stove, or campfire to the table.
- EASY TO USE: Give your cooking an upgrade by using cast iron cookware. Durable, rugged, and made to last, this cast iron pizza pan is easy to use and will last through years of great meals. With a few simple steps, our griddle will last a lifetime.
- VERSATILE: Our cast iron griddle is made with natural materials and can be used almost anywhere, such as on gas, electric, or ceramic stove tops; on induction cooktops; in an oven; over a campfire; or on a grill. Your food will stay warm for longer and will be infused with beneficial natural iron.
- FROM STOVE TO TABLE: Victoria has manufactured quality cast iron cookware in our own factories in Colombia—never outsourcing—since 1939. Our cast iron products are made with resource-efficient materials, are economical, outlast traditional cookware, and offer reliable cooking for years to come.
8. Nostalgia MyMini Personal Sandwich Maker – Best Mini
For small servings or on-the-go cooking, the Nostalgia MyMini Personal Sandwich Maker is a versatile option. Though not specifically a quesadilla maker, it can easily handle 5-inch folded tortillas and make a variety of dishes like omelets, handheld pies, pizza pockets, and more. Its compact and lightweight design makes it perfect for college dorms, RVs, offices, and small kitchens.
- ON THE GO MEALS: Quick and healthier way to cook hot sandwiches, pizza pockets, panini pockets, quesadilla pockets, grilled cheese, and breakfast sandwiches
- MORE THAN SANDWICHES: Also can be used to cook omelets, french toast, waffles, pies, cakes, & other desserts
- EASY TO USE: Simply plug it in, wait 1-3 minutes until preheated and when the indicator light shuts off you can begin cooking
- COMPACT & LIGHTWEIGHT: Its small size makes it the perfect fit for any kitchen, apartment, office, dorm and camper/RV
- DUAL-SIDED COOKING SURFACE: Each cooking surface is 5-inches wide – providing quick, efficient and consistent results. The nonstick surface easily wipes clean
How to Choose the Perfect Quesadilla Maker
When choosing the right quesadilla maker, consider the following factors:
Size:
Select a quesadilla maker that matches the tortilla size you prefer. Most models come in 8-inch or 10-inch sizes, while others can accommodate larger tortillas.
Material:
Opt for a quesadilla maker with a nonstick coating to ensure easy release of your quesadilla and simple cleanup. Nonstick coatings make cooking and cleaning hassle-free.
Budget:
Consider your budget and choose a quesadilla maker that fits within your price range. There are excellent options available at various price points.
Purpose:
Decide on the primary purpose of your quesadilla maker. If you want a dedicated appliance for quesadillas only, choose one specifically designed for this purpose. If you prefer a multi-use appliance, look for indoor grills with quesadilla-making capabilities.
Additional Features:
Some quesadilla makers come with additional features like removable plates, indicator lights, and storage designs. Evaluate these features to find the one that suits your needs best.
Conclusion
In conclusion, the best quesadilla maker for you depends on your personal preferences and needs. Whether you’re looking for an affordable option, a high-end multipurpose grill, or a versatile outdoor cooking companion, there’s a quesadilla maker out there for you. With our top picks and buying guide, you’re well-equipped to choose the perfect quesadilla maker to take your quesadilla-making skills to the next level. So break out the salsa and sour cream, and let your quesadilla maker turn every meal into a flavorful fiesta. Happy quesadilla-making!
FAQ – Best Quesadilla Maker
Do quesadilla makers work?
Quesadilla makers are designed specifically for making quesadillas, and they work efficiently to cook and seal the tortillas with the desired fillings.
What pan is best for quesadillas?
A quesadilla maker with non-stick plates is ideal, as it ensures easy release and cleaning.
Can I use uncooked tortillas in a quesadilla maker?
Yes, you can use uncooked tortillas in a quesadilla maker as they will cook during the process.
Should I cook quesadilla in oil or butter?
You can use either oil or butter, depending on your preference, to add flavor and prevent sticking.
Do you spray the pan when making quesadillas?
If using a traditional pan, it’s advisable to lightly spray it with cooking oil or use a non-stick pan.
Do you use cooking spray with a quesadilla maker?
Most quesadilla makers have non-stick surfaces, so you generally don’t need to use cooking spray.
How to make the perfect quesadilla in a quesadilla maker?
Spread your fillings evenly on one side of the tortilla, fold it in half, and then place it in the preheated quesadilla maker until it’s golden and crispy.
How long to cook a quesadilla in a quesadilla maker?
The cooking time may vary depending on the maker, but it typically takes 3-5 minutes to achieve a crispy texture.
What else can you use a quesadilla maker for?
Apart from quesadillas, you can use a quesadilla maker to make grilled sandwiches, wraps, and even certain types of omelets.
Can you cook a hamburger in a quesadilla maker?
A quesadilla maker is not suitable for cooking hamburgers, as it is designed for flat items like quesadillas.
Can I use small tortillas on a quesadilla maker?
Yes, you can use small tortillas, but make sure the fillings are appropriately distributed to avoid spilling.
Can you cook eggs in a quesadilla maker?
Yes, you can make scrambled eggs or omelets in a quesadilla maker, provided it has a high enough heat capacity.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon.com, Inc, or its affiliates.
